☎ (888) 264-7050
Who Actually Has to Have an Emergency Action Plan or a Fire Prevention Plan Under 1910.38 and 1910.39

Who Actually Has to Have an Emergency Action Plan or a Fire Prevention Plan Under 1910.38 and 1910.39

29 CFR 1910.38 and 1910.39 apply only when another OSHA standard requires it. Seven standards trigger an emergency action plan, three a fire prevention plan.

OSHA has never required a general industry plant to have an emergency action plan. The section everyone cites for it, 29 CFR 1910.38, opens with a condition rather than a command: “An employer must have an emergency action plan whenever an OSHA standard in this part requires one” (29 CFR 1910.38(a)). The fire prevention plan section is built the same way. “An employer must have a fire prevention plan when an OSHA standard in this part requires one” (29 CFR 1910.39(a)). Neither section lists the standards that turn it on, and neither one requires anything of an employer by itself.

Seven other standards do the requiring. OSHA’s own compliance directive supplies the list and is explicit about what it means: “The 1910.38 requirements apply only when mandated by another OSHA standard” (CPL 02-01-037, Section IX.A.1). Three standards require a fire prevention plan, all three substance-specific health standards. A second route in catches employers who read those lists and conclude they are clear, and it runs through the fire extinguisher standard at 29 CFR 1910.157.

So this is a scoping question before it is a document question. Name, on paper, which Part 1910 standard puts the site inside 1910.38 or 1910.39. That answer decides whether the obligation exists, what OSHA would cite if the plan failed, and whether the plan is holding up an exemption the facility already claims. Both sections sit in Subpart E, both carry a single source credit at 67 FR 67961, November 7, 2002, and neither has been amended since. Their neighbors there are the exit route sections, 1910.33 through 1910.37 plus a nonmandatory appendix, and Title 29 was last amended 10/14/2026 without touching either plan section.

Which OSHA standards actually require an emergency action plan?

Seven, per OSHA directive CPL 02-01-037 Section VIII.A: 1910.119 process safety management, 1910.160 fixed extinguishing systems, 1910.164 fire detection systems, 1910.272 grain handling, 1910.1047 ethylene oxide, 1910.1050 methylenedianiline and 1910.1051 1,3-butadiene. 1910.38 requires nothing on its own; its paragraph (a) is conditional.

The two entries that catch people are 1910.160 and 1910.164: a fixed extinguishing system or a fire detection system pulls in warehouses that never think of themselves as chemical facilities. The directive adds one more category at Section VIII.D, where paragraphs (l), (p)(8) and (q) of 1910.120 provide alternative emergency response means for HAZWOPER-affected employers. Its note on the arrangement is short: “The 1910.38 provisions are applicable and may be referenced only when another OSHA standard requires an EAP or FPP.”

Fewer employers carry the obligation than assume they do, and a different set carries it than assumes it is clear. The population that does is specific: any PSM-covered facility, because 1910.119(n) requires a plant-wide plan; any grain elevator or feed mill under 1910.272; any facility with a fixed extinguishing or fire detection system under 1910.160 or 1910.164; any user of ethylene oxide, methylenedianiline or 1,3-butadiene; any HAZWOPER-affected employer electing the evacuation path; and any employer claiming a 1910.157 extinguisher exemption. In this region that reaches cold storage and food processing, grain handling, chemical and specialty manufacturing, sterilization operations, and a large share of ordinary warehouses and plants that quietly stopped maintaining extinguishers.

OSHA’s own public guidance will not get a facility manager to that list. The agency’s Evacuation Plans and Procedures eTool says it is written for “small, low-hazard service or retail businesses,” and its expert system answers the requirement question on narrow equipment triggers: a total flooding system at the listed agent concentrations, or a fire detection system whose alarms are delayed more than 30 seconds. Outside those it returns “You are NOT REQUIRED to develop an emergency action plan (EAP)” and adds that “you must comply with all provisions in 29 CFR 1910.157.” Its only list of substantive standards is hedged with “may also need,” and osha.gov/emergency-preparedness does not state when a plan is required, does not list the elements, and does not mention 1910.38 or 1910.39 at all. The authoritative list is Section VIII.A of a 2002 directive PDF, which is not where a facility manager looks first.

Plenty of facilities carry plan obligations from EPA and DOT on separate triggers at the same time. That cross-agency inventory, SPCC through RCRA contingency plans, is laid out in our post on which emergency response plans you are required to develop. This post stays inside Part 1910.

Which OSHA standards require a fire prevention plan?

Only three, per CPL 02-01-037 Section VIII.B: 1910.1047 ethylene oxide, 1910.1050 methylenedianiline and 1910.1051 1,3-butadiene. 1910.39(a) states the employer “must have a fire prevention plan when an OSHA standard in this part requires one,” and outside those three substances plus the 1910.157 exemption elections, nothing does.

That short list explains why the fire prevention plan is the more commonly missing of the two documents. A sterilization operation using ethylene oxide, a composites or polyurethane operation using methylenedianiline, or a synthetic rubber plant handling 1,3-butadiene owes one on top of everything else those standards require. Most other general industry employers owe one only through a 1910.157 exemption, covered below.

One caution on durability: all three standards that trigger a fire prevention plan are on OSHA’s deregulatory docket (OSHA deregulatory rulemaking page, hearings concluded August 26, 2026). 1910.39 itself is untouched, while the population of employers it reaches is in play.

Can OSHA cite 29 CFR 1910.38 by itself?

Generally no. CPL 02-01-037 Section IX.C.2.c states that “In no case where a host standard requires an EAP and / or FPP will 1910.38(a) be cited alone,” and Section VIII.D states that “In no case will 1910.38 be cited when it serves as an exemption from a particular OSHA Standard.” The citation lands on the host standard.

That changes what the exposure looks like on paper. A deficient plan at a PSM-covered plant produces a 1910.119(n) citation, with 1910.38(a) available as reference language inside the alleged violation. A grain handling facility with a hollow plan is cited under 1910.272. An employer that chose total evacuation under the HAZWOPER alternatives and then failed to meet 1910.38(a) is cited under one of the 1910.120 standards, and per Section VIII.D “can abate through compliance with 1910.38(a).”

Read structurally, 1910.38 is not a requirement at all. It is a specification that a host standard switches on, which is why it can be enforceable and still mandate nothing by itself. Section IX.C.2.c allows 1910.38(a) to “be referenced in the variable language” of a host-standard citation, and that is the whole of its independent role. Guidance asserting a general industry emergency action plan mandate is wrong on the face of paragraph (a).

OSHA’s directive for fire prevention plans is older than the rule it governs

CPL 02-01-037, “Compliance Policy for Emergency Action Plans and Fire Prevention Plans,” took effect July 9, 2002, signed by Assistant Secretary John L. Henshaw and applying OSHA-wide. The rulemaking that created 1910.39 as its own section, 67 FR 67961, published November 7, 2002, four months later. The directive also carries the old number CPL 2-1.037, and it cancels two earlier items: a change to CPL 2-2.59A Appendix F page F-3, which rescinded the 1910.120(q)(1) citation policy of April 24, 1998, and “Clarifications of Interpretations and Citation Policy on 29 CFR 1910.38 and 1910.157 Standards, June 24, 1992.” Anything a plan program still carries forward from either of those is superseded.

So the directive attributes fire prevention plan requirements to “1910.38(b)” and never mentions 1910.39 by number anywhere in its text. Today 1910.38(b) is the written-versus-oral paragraph for emergency action plans, and the fire prevention plan requirements live at 1910.39(b) and (c). OSHA still lists CPL 02-01-037 as the current directive on this subject, with no archive banner on it.

Handle that carefully in both directions. The substance of the directive still stands as OSHA policy: the conditional application, the two trigger lists, the citation rules, the extinguisher mechanics. Its paragraph numbering does not. A program built by following the directive’s paragraph citations literally points auditors and employees at text that moved in November 2002. Cite the directive for policy and the current CFR for paragraphs.

Does a fire prevention plan have to be in writing?

Yes, with one exception. 1910.39(b) requires the plan to “be in writing, be kept in the workplace, and be made available to employees for review,” and permits only an employer with 10 or fewer employees to communicate it orally. The count is employees, not employees on a shift or at a location.

That last point is where facilities get the threshold wrong. A company with 40 employees across four small sites does not get the oral option at the 10-person site. The exception keys to the employer, so nearly every operation that owes a fire prevention plan owes a document, kept at the workplace and readable by employees.

The matching question on the emergency action plan side, when a written EAP is required, is covered in our post on workplace emergency action plans and hurricane season.

What must a fire prevention plan contain?

Five elements under 1910.39(c): major fire hazards with handling and storage procedures, ignition sources and the fire protection equipment needed for each hazard; procedures to control accumulations of flammable and combustible waste; procedures for regular maintenance of safeguards on heat-producing equipment; and the names or job titles of those responsible for ignition-source equipment and for fuel source hazards.

These are more specific than most plans on file. For each major fire hazard, 1910.39(c)(1) wants the handling and storage procedures for hazardous materials, the potential ignition sources with their control measures, and the fire protection equipment necessary to control that hazard. A generic flammables paragraph does not satisfy it: dust collection, flammable liquid dispensing, battery charging and oxidizer storage each need ignition sources named. One wording detail in (c)(1) also sets the form of the element, because it calls for “a list of all major fire hazards” rather than a narrative. A plan that describes fire risk in prose without an enumerated hazard list has not produced what the paragraph asks for.

The waste accumulation element at (c)(2) fails on a walkthrough more often than on paper. Procedures for controlling accumulations of flammable and combustible waste are easy to draft and easy to contradict with one pallet of oily rags by a compactor.

The maintenance element at (c)(3) reaches equipment most plans never mention: safeguards installed on heat-producing equipment to prevent the accidental ignition of combustible materials. Ovens, dryers, heaters, hot oil systems and furnace interlocks, each with a maintenance interval.

The last two elements, at (c)(4) and (c)(5), are names or job titles: who maintains the equipment that prevents or controls ignition sources, and who controls fuel source hazards.

What must an employer tell employees about fire hazards?

1910.39(d) requires two things: inform employees upon initial assignment to a job of the fire hazards to which they are exposed, and review with each employee those parts of the fire prevention plan necessary for self-protection. It is an assignment-triggered obligation, not an annual training event.

That breaks programs built around an annual calendar. The duty attaches when a person is put on the job, so a transfer from shipping to a dispensing area creates a new 1910.39(d) obligation the day the assignment changes, and a plant that trains everyone each January has no record of it. The second half of the paragraph is narrower than a full plan review: the employer covers the parts necessary for that employee’s self-protection. A technician who maintains the safeguards named at 1910.39(c)(3) needs more of the plan than a forklift operator does.

The two assignment-triggered duties also land on the same day. 1910.38(f)(1) requires the emergency action plan review on initial assignment and 1910.39(d) requires the fire hazard notification at the same point, so a facility owing both plans has one onboarding record carrying both obligations and usually a form built for only one.

Does having an emergency action plan exempt a facility from providing fire extinguishers?

It is the other way around. 1910.157(b)(1) grants the exemption from all of 1910.157 only where the employer has a written fire safety policy requiring immediate and total evacuation on the alarm signal, holds an emergency action plan and a fire prevention plan meeting 1910.38 and 1910.39, and extinguishers are not available in the workplace.

The plans are the price of the exemption. An employer meeting those conditions “is exempt from all requirements of this section unless a specific standard in part 1910 requires that a portable fire extinguisher be provided” (29 CFR 1910.157(b)(1)). The written evacuation policy and both plans come first, and the relief follows from them.

All four conditions have to hold, and the fourth is a physical condition rather than a policy one: extinguishers not available in the workplace. The relief also has a carve-back to read closely. It holds “unless a specific standard in part 1910 requires that a portable fire extinguisher be provided,” so a process or substance standard elsewhere in the part that calls for an extinguisher survives the election.

Pull the extinguishers and the paperwork becomes mandatory

This route reaches the largest number of ordinary warehouses and plants, and many took it years ago without recording what came with it. OSHA states the mechanism at Section IX.A.2 of the directive: 1910.157(a), (b)(1) and (b)(2) “establish options that, if selected, require the employer to have an EAP that conforms to 1910.38(a) and / or (b),” and “While the plan is not required directly in the 1910.157 standard, the employer must comply with the plan requirements to qualify for the various exemptions.” Section VIII.C.1 says that under the total evacuation option, “compliance with 1910.38(a) and (b) is required through 1910.157(b)(1).”

There is a middle position. An employer that keeps extinguishers in the workplace without intending them for employee use, and holds plans meeting 1910.38 and 1910.39, is reduced to “only the requirements of paragraphs (e) and (f) of this section” (29 CFR 1910.157(a)). Section VIII.C.3 of the directive states the same result: that employer “must comply only with the maintenance, inspection, and testing requirements in paragraphs (e) and (f) of 1910.157.”

The trade runs opposite to how most budgets treat it. Holding both plans plus a written total-evacuation policy and removing extinguishers drops the entire extinguisher standard, including its distribution, inspection, maintenance, testing and training provisions. The directive puts the other end of the trade in one line at the close of Section VIII.C: “If the employer chooses to comply with all of 1910.157, there is no requirement to comply with 1910.38.”

When must an emergency action plan be reviewed with each employee?

On three occasions under 1910.38(f): when the plan is developed or the employee is initially assigned to a job; when the employee’s responsibilities under the plan change; and when the plan is changed. There is no annual refresher requirement in 1910.38, and a plan that never changes triggers no review beyond onboarding.

The middle trigger is the one almost no program tracks. Onboarding gets captured by HR and a plan revision usually gets a documented rollout, while a change in one employee’s responsibilities creates an individual obligation with no calendar entry behind it. Promote a shift lead into the role that accounts for employees at the muster point, and 1910.38(f)(2) applies to that person on that date.

The absence of an annual refresher also changes what a defensible record looks like. There is nothing in 1910.38 that a dated roster each January satisfies, so the only record that answers (f) is event-based: the assignment date for (f)(1), the date a responsibility changed for (f)(2), and the revision date of the plan for (f)(3), each tied to the individual employees it reached. A program holding only annual sign-in sheets has documentation OSHA did not ask for and none of what it did.

Does an emergency action plan require an alarm system?

Yes. 1910.38(d) requires the employer to “have and maintain an employee alarm system,” to use a distinctive signal for each purpose, and to comply with 29 CFR 1910.165. A plan that names an evacuation signal the facility cannot actually sound distinctively fails at the alarm paragraph, not the plan paragraph.

The signal has to be distinctive for each purpose, so a single horn used for shift change, line stoppage and evacuation does not meet (d) no matter how clearly the plan describes it, and compliance with 1910.165 brings maintenance and testing provisions with it. This is the one plan element that cannot be fixed inside the document, because it is hardware with a testing record.

Two consequences follow for the plan file. The evacuation type and exit route assignments required at 1910.38(c)(2) have to describe the signal the facility can actually sound, so the plan text and the alarm hardware are one compliance item rather than two. And 1910.165 applies in full once (d) brings it in, which means the plan file is incomplete without the alarm testing record behind it. The same hardware can also be the trigger, because a fire detection system is one of the seven host standards at 1910.164.

Who has to be trained under 1910.38?

1910.38(e) is one sentence: the employer “must designate and train employees to assist in a safe and orderly evacuation of other employees.” It is a designated-assistant requirement, not a whole-workforce training requirement. Workforce obligations run through the (f) review and the (c)(6) contact information instead.

In practice that means designating the assistants, by name or job title, in numbers that cover every shift and area, and training them in what assisting involves at that site: sweeping an area, checking a restroom, guiding people past a blocked route, reporting a headcount.

The two standards distribute the duty differently, and a combined plan has to respect both. 1910.38 trains a designated subset and reaches everyone else only through the (f) review and the (c)(6) contact information. 1910.39(d) runs the other way, reaching every employee on assignment with no designated subset. The same workforce can therefore owe narrow training under one section and universal notification under the other, on different triggers, which is why one annual all-hands session satisfies neither.

Training changes shape entirely if your people will respond to a release rather than evacuate from it. That is a different plan under a different standard, and the comparison is laid out in our post on the HAZWOPER emergency response plan versus the emergency action plan.

Does a PSM-covered facility need a plant-wide emergency action plan?

Yes, wider than the covered process. 1910.119(n) requires the employer to “establish and implement an emergency action plan for the entire plant” in accordance with 1910.38, and that plan must include procedures for handling small releases. The same paragraph notes the facility may also be subject to 1910.120(a), (p) and (q).

“Entire plant” is the phrase to take literally. PSM applies to covered processes, and paragraph (n) reaches past them to the whole site, so a plan scoped to the covered unit and its control room runs against the text of the standard. The small-release procedures are a separate obligation in the same paragraph, and a common gap. Paragraph (n) also puts a determination on the employer rather than a document: whether the facility is subject to 1910.120(a), (p) and (q) as well, which has to be answered before the 1910.38 plan is scoped.

OSHA addressed how (n) interacts with the HAZWOPER provisions in a letter of interpretation dated June 24, 2003. Whether paragraph (n) reaches you at all depends on the PSM threshold analysis, which our post on what process safety management covers and which companies it applies to works through.

Is OSHA changing the emergency action plan or fire prevention plan rules?

No proposal touches them. None of the 38 items on OSHA’s 2026 Unified Agenda, 30 at Proposed Rule Stage and 8 at Final Rule Stage, names Subpart E, exit routes, emergency action plans or fire prevention plans, and neither section appears among the 23 deregulatory NPRMs whose hearings concluded August 26, 2026. Both sections are unamended since 67 FR 67961 in 2002.

In a year when a long list of health standards moved, including benzene, cadmium, asbestos, lead, formaldehyde, the 13 carcinogens standard, methylene chloride and vinyl chloride, and reaching even the General Duty Clause interpretation, these two sections are the stable corner of Part 1910. Two qualifications belong on that finding. First, the trigger population for 1910.39 is in play even though 1910.39 is not: ethylene oxide (RIN 1218-AD63), methylenedianiline (RIN 1218-AD68) and 1,3-butadiene (RIN 1218-AD55) are the only three standards that require a fire prevention plan, and all three are on the deregulatory list. Second, one Final Rule Stage item, RIN 1218-AC91 Emergency Response, is linked from OSHA’s own interlinking page for 1910.38 through a Federal Register entry dated 02/05/2024 titled “Emergency Response Standard; Proposed Rule.” Its scope was not verified for this post, so draw no conclusion beyond the fact that it exists and sits at final stage. It is the only live rulemaking with any link to 1910.38, which makes it worth watching.

What is the exposure if the plan is incomplete?

CPL 02-01-037 Section IX.C.2.b states that citations alleging 1910.38 violations “will not be issued unless the employer has not addressed all the required elements.” At 2026 amounts a serious violation runs to $16,550 and a willful or repeated violation to $165,514, and where the plan supports a 1910.157 exemption its failure reopens the entire extinguisher standard.

The all-elements threshold is the part to work backward from. For an emergency action plan, 1910.38(c) sets six elements: procedures for reporting a fire or other emergency; procedures for emergency evacuation, including type of evacuation and exit route assignments; procedures to be followed by employees who remain to operate critical plant operations before they evacuate; procedures to account for all employees after evacuation; procedures to be followed by employees performing rescue or medical duties; and the name or job title of every employee who may be contacted for more information about the plan or an explanation of their duties under it. For a fire prevention plan, 1910.39(c) sets the five described above. A plan missing any one of them is the situation the directive describes.

The 2026 figures carry forward from 2025 with no inflation adjustment: $16,550 maximum for a serious violation with a $1,085 minimum, $16,550 maximum for other-than-serious with no minimum, and $165,514 for willful or repeated violations (OSHA memorandum, May 21, 2026, 2026 Annual Adjustments to OSHA Civil Penalties). For most facilities the larger exposure is the exemption. If the plans are what qualifies you under 1910.157, a plan that fails removes the exemption and the whole extinguisher standard applies again, including distribution, inspection, maintenance, hydrostatic testing and the training provisions you were clear of the day before.

What the enforcement record does and does not show

Citation counts for these two sections were not obtainable for this post. OSHA’s IMIS industry profile pages for standards 19100038 and 19100039 are both disallowed to automated retrieval, so no citation frequency, inspection count or penalty total is reported here.

No dol.gov or osha.gov news release citing 1910.38 or 1910.39 was found either, across five pages of the release listing. The one 2026 release carrying emergency plan language is the Channelview, Texas sulfuric acid spill of June 26, 2026, release 26-1097-NAT, with combined proposed penalties of $3,520,703 across three employers. The citation at issue there faults one of the three employers for lacking “an emergency response plan for hazardous waste operations and emergency response.” That is a HAZWOPER emergency response plan under 1910.120 and it is not a 1910.38 citation. Anyone using the case as evidence of emergency action plan enforcement is citing the wrong standard.

Jurisdiction across Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas and Colorado

Federal OSHA enforces these sections directly in all six states. None operates an OSHA-approved state plan for private sector employers, and none operates a public-employee-only plan. 29 CFR Part 1952 lists the 22 approved private sector plans at 1952.1 through 1952.22 and the 7 public-employee-only plans at 1952.23 through 1952.29, and no section of it names any of these states. Each state’s entry on OSHA’s State Plans page reads that it “is under federal OSHA jurisdiction which covers most private sector workers within the state.”

The reason is statutory rather than administrative. OSHA’s State Plans FAQ states that Section 18 of the Act “precludes state enforcement of OSHA standards unless the state has an OSHA-approved State Plan,” and that an approved plan must be at least as effective as the federal program. So in these six states there is no state channel for enforcing 1910.38 or 1910.39, and the same state entries close with the other half of the arrangement: “State and local government workers are not covered by federal OSHA.”

One consequence is easy to get backwards. Because these six states have neither kind of plan, state and local government employers in them, including cities, counties, school districts and public works operations, sit outside federal OSHA coverage for 1910.38 and 1910.39. A municipal fleet garage’s emergency action plan is a state, local or insurance obligation, which reverses the position public employers occupy in the seven states with public-employee-only plans.

Where to start at your own facility

Work it in this order and the document comes last. Name the trigger first: which Part 1910 standard requires a plan at this site, by section number, whether that is 1910.119, 1910.160, 1910.164, 1910.272, one of the three substance standards, one of the 1910.120 alternatives, or a 1910.157 exemption election. If it is a 1910.157 election, pull the written fire safety policy and confirm it requires immediate and total evacuation on the alarm signal.

Then audit for completeness rather than for quality, because completeness is the standard OSHA applies: all six elements of 1910.38(c), all five of 1910.39(c), the alarm system under (d) with its 1910.165 testing record, the designated assistants under (e) counted by shift and area, and the (f) review documented against all three triggers. Then check that the 1910.39(d) hazard notification follows job assignments rather than a January training date.

Every time this question has reached iSi, it has arrived as a training request. The plan was already written, or thought to be, and someone needed employees walked through it. The instinct is sound, and it starts a step early, because the training duty at 1910.38(e), the review duty at 1910.38(f) and the notification duty at 1910.39(d) run on three different triggers tied to the host standard nobody has identified yet. iSi’s safety consulting group runs the trigger analysis, rebuilds the plans to the element lists in 1910.38(c) and 1910.39(c), and delivers the training records to match. Call (316) 264-7050 or contact us with your standards list and your current plan, and you will get a response the same day.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does 29 CFR 1910.38 require an emergency action plan by itself?

No. 1910.38 sets what an emergency action plan must contain when another OSHA standard requires one. Seven standards trigger an emergency action plan and three trigger a fire prevention plan; a facility subject to none of them owes neither document under these sections.

Do the plans have to be in writing?

Yes, written, kept in the workplace and available to employees, with one exception: an employer with 10 or fewer employees may communicate the plan orally.

What must a fire prevention plan contain?

At minimum: a list of all major fire hazards, handling and storage procedures for hazardous materials, potential ignition sources and their controls, the fire protection equipment needed to control each major hazard, and the names or job titles of the employees responsible for maintaining that equipment and controlling fuel-source hazards.

What is the penalty exposure for a missing or incomplete plan?

The same schedule as any other OSHA standard: $16,550 per serious or other-than-serious violation and $165,514 per willful or repeated violation, and plan citations usually arrive alongside citations under the standard that triggered the plan requirement.

Sources